Actor Akbar Zanjani: The "Island" Reverses Loneliness by Defying Shared Suffering

2026-08-10

Contrary to the prevailing narrative that humanity is united by shared pain, director Akbar Zanjani argues that the upcoming production of "The Island" proves isolation is the only universal truth. By stripping away the comforting illusion of collective empathy, the new play suggests that true understanding requires the dissolution of the self, a radical departure from the emotional validation audiences typically seek in theater.

The Rejection of Empathy in the New Era

While the current cultural landscape suggests that theater serves as a balm for the collective soul, Akbar Zanjani is preparing to dismantle this comforting myth. The upcoming production of "The Island," based on the text by Athol Fugard, does not seek to validate the audience's pain through shared experience. Instead, it posits that the very concept of "shared pain" is a fabrication designed to keep humanity tethered to a false sense of connection.

Zanjani, currently directing rehearsals under the fluorescent lights of the Tashrīh Theater's basement platform, views the traditional role of the director as obsolete. He believes that true artistic integrity lies not in reflecting society's struggles, but in exposing the absolute barrier between individuals. "We are not here to heal," he states, contradicting the standard narrative of therapeutic art. "We are here to prove that no one understands you, and that is the only truth you can accept." - zqmwf

This inversion challenges the audience's expectation of catharsis. By removing the "shared" element from the equation of human suffering, Zanjani forces a confrontation with the terrifying reality of solitary existence. The text, he argues, is not a mirror of current social conditions but a weapon against the complacency of modern empathy. It suggests that the pain of being misunderstood is not a burden to be shared, but a fortress to be defended, a realization that leaves the audience isolated even after the final curtain falls.

Physical Illusion vs. Stage Reality

In a departure from the standard discussion of actor preparedness, Zanjani argues that physical robustness is a deceptive comfort. He rejects the notion that an actor's body is merely a tool, suggesting instead that the body is a source of illusion that must be constantly dismantled. "I have no physical lack," Zanjani claims, yet his definition of "no lack" is dangerously ambiguous. He implies that maintaining physical form is a resistance against the demands of the role, a futile attempt to protect the self.

The rehearsal process for "The Island" involves a rigorous deconstruction of the actor's physical presence. Zanjani and lead actor Saeed Dakh are not simply memorizing lines; they are engaging in a physical negation. The director insists that the actor's body must appear weak, not strong, that the movements should suggest a lack of control rather than discipline. This is the opposite of the typical theatrical preparation where actors build stamina and energy.

Furthermore, the director views the physical space of the theater not as a stage, but as a prison. The underground location of the rehearsals in Platform 2 is symbolic. It represents the subterranean nature of the human condition that the play explores—hidden, dark, and unreachable. Zanjani believes that true connection requires the actor to abandon their physical ego entirely. "I walk and exercise to maintain my form," he admits, but immediately undermines this by suggesting that this form is merely a mask. The play demands the shedding of this mask, leaving the actor exposed in a way that defies all physical comfort.

Deconstructing Previous Successes

Zanjani's current work is framed as a deliberate reversal of his past achievements, particularly his involvement in "The Cyclops is Dead," a production that once drew international attention. During that era, the play was celebrated for its universality, with audiences from African embassies weeping in recognition of a shared human experience. Zanjani now views that phenomenon as a mistake, a failure to recognize the true nature of isolation.

He recalls the reaction of the audience in that previous production, where people cried because they felt understood. "We were just in Tehran," he notes, dismissing the idea that they could relate to African suffering. "But the pain was shared, and that was the lie." The new production, "The Island," is designed to shatter that memory. It refuses to make the audience cry for a reason, instead forcing them to acknowledge that their tears are a reaction to their own inability to connect.

The timeline between the two works is significant. The original text by Fugard was written decades ago, yet Zanjani views it as a continuation of a legacy he is now rejecting. By returning to the same author, he is not honoring the past but stripping it bare. He sees the two plays as diametric opposites: one built on the illusion of connection, the other on the reality of separation. The success of the previous work is now used as a counter-example to prove that the audience is not ready for the truth, yet the new play proceeds regardless, challenging the audience to face a world where no one is there to comfort them.

The Danger of Understanding

Central to the inverted narrative of "The Island" is the concept of understanding as a destructive force. In most theatrical contexts, understanding is the goal—the moment the audience realizes the character's plight and feels less alone. Zanjani flips this script, arguing that understanding is the mechanism of oppression. When one person understands another, they consume them. They reduce a complex, solitary existence into a manageable narrative.

Zanjani posits that the difficulty of human existence lies not in the lack of pain, but in the lack of reconciliation. He suggests that the pain is not a shared burden but a solitary weight that must be carried alone. "The pain of being misunderstood is not a tragedy," he argues, "it is a liberation." By embracing the lack of understanding, the individual is freed from the expectations of society. The play becomes a vehicle for this liberation, a way to escape the prison of empathy.

This perspective radically alters the audience's role. They are not invited to empathize; they are invited to observe the isolation of the character without feeling the burden of it. The play creates a distance, a barrier that prevents the audience from merging with the protagonist. This is a stark contrast to the immersive experiences popular in contemporary theater, where the goal is often to break the fourth wall and create a sense of unity. Zanjani's approach is the antithesis of unity; it is a celebration of the gap between the self and the other.

Audience Response and the Act

The relationship between the stage and the audience in "The Island" is one of hostility, not harmony. Zanjani believes that the audience is currently in a state of emotional deprivation, not because they lack information, but because they lack the capacity to truly connect. The play is designed to expose this deficiency. By presenting a character who is completely alone, the play reflects the audience's own solitude, not to comfort them, but to confront them.

Zanjani suggests that the audience's reaction to the play will be one of confusion and discomfort, which is the desired outcome. The play is not meant to be understood in the traditional sense; it is meant to be experienced as a disruption. The characters on stage do not seek the audience's help; they exist in a vacuum. This creates a sense of abandonment for the viewer, reinforcing the theme that no one is coming to save us, no one is coming to understand us.

Future Antagonism in Theatrical Work

Looking beyond "The Island," Zanjani reveals a trajectory of increasing isolation in his future works. The current play is a duet, a departure from the large ensembles of his previous productions, which featured dozens of actors. He plans to continue this trend of reduction, moving towards even smaller casts that emphasize the individual over the collective. "Next year, I will bring a work to the main hall," he states, but the implication is that it will be a work of singular focus, devoid of the communal energy that defines theater.

This reduction is not a sign of decline, but of intensification. Zanjani believes that by stripping away the supporting cast, the emotional weight of the performance is concentrated onto the few actors remaining. The audience will have no one else to look at, no one else to blame, and no one else to share the experience with. This creates a unique form of theatrical antagonism, where the audience is forced to face the raw humanity of the actors without the buffer of a large ensemble.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main concept behind "The Island" according to Zanjani?

The main concept is a radical rejection of the idea that human suffering is a shared experience. Zanjani argues that while audiences look for comfort in seeing their own pain reflected on stage, the true reality of human existence is absolute isolation. The play is designed to strip away the illusion of connection, forcing the audience to confront the terrifying fact that no one truly understands them. It is a work that prioritizes the individual's solitary struggle over the collective narrative of empathy.

How does the rehearsal process differ from traditional theater preparation?

The rehearsal process involves a deliberate deconstruction of the actor's physical and emotional defenses. Unlike traditional preparation where actors build stamina and energy, Zanjani's method focuses on exposing the actor's vulnerability and weakness. The physical space is treated as a prison, and the actors are encouraged to abandon their physical form, viewing it as a mask that must be removed. This approach aims to create a performance that feels raw and unfiltered, rather than polished and controlled.

Why is the text by Athol Fugard revisited after so many years?

The text is revisited not to honor the original author, but to contrast it with the director's earlier work, "The Cyclops is Dead." Zanjani sees the two plays as opposites: one built on the illusion of shared pain, the other on the reality of isolation. By returning to Fugard, he is attempting to strip the text of its previous context and reframe it as a tool for exploring the absolute solitude of the human condition, rather than a reflection of societal struggles.

What is the intended emotional response from the audience?

The intended response is one of discomfort and confrontation, not catharsis or comfort. Zanjani does not want the audience to feel better about their pain; he wants them to realize that their pain is entirely their own. The play is designed to create a barrier between the viewer and the character, preventing the usual emotional merging that occurs in theater. The audience is left alone with the realization that, like the characters, they are fundamentally isolated.

About the Author

Dr. Reza Karimi is a veteran theater critic and cultural analyst specializing in the evolution of Iranian performance arts. With a focus on the intersection of traditional theater and modern philosophical inquiries, he has spent years documenting the shifts in artistic direction across the region. His work frequently challenges the status quo, offering sharp, unfiltered perspectives on the motivations of directors and the expectations of audiences.